
Chris Columbus has finally made his way back across the pond to direct a film, does it have the same magic as before?
The Thursday Murder Club is a crossover of true crime and British comedy that fans of each should find something to latch on to. With a stacked cast of Helen Mirren, Ben Kingsley, and Pierce Brosnan there’s a lot of grand personalities to enjoy. There’s a whimsical nature to this cast that makes this a lot of fun. The never aging Kingsley is a delight plus Mirren and Brosnan are just playing themselves, which is all you need from them at this stage in their careers. Celia Imrie is the bright eyed newcomer to the club and Naomi Ackie is the helpful rookie cop, together these five make for a great team of “professional” and “retired” detectives. It cleverly uses its characters to misdirect and keep up the intrigue.
Having a murder club set in a retirement home was such a fun idea, that it’s pretty much Hogwarts for old people. Set in a beautiful castle, this set defines what type of story this is going to be. The story and its characters are so polite that it almost doesn’t feel like a murder mystery. It was a pleasure to see characters in this realm still find joy in something and not get complacent with where they are, it gives me hope for my future. There’s a lot of fight in the outcome, evidence to joyfully unfold, and refusement in abundance that adds amusement to the conflict.
The story does become convoluted and could have benefited from being a quicker film. I get wanting screentime for everyone, but a lot of that screentime is wasted on painfully added circumstantial ploys. The seriousness was overdone and worked better when played like an ukulele instead of a bass. Also, like Alzheimer’s, this tells similar beats multiple times just in different ways. Chris Columbus still knows how to direct a funny and entertaining story, but it is missing a stand out role or a more fantastical story.
It can’t be denied that this cast is quite possibly the best ensemble on the year. They make me wish I knew more of the work indiviually. This solves the problem on how to get reasonable chemsitry out of your cast but doesn’t add too much to the thriller genre. This is bloody decent while also not being fully original with its murder plot.
This falls somewhere between Murder Mystery and Knives Out when compared to other Netflix whodunits.
6.1/10








