
Why yes, I would like to put my name in the running to spend eternity with Elizabeth Olsen.
I don’t love to complain, but I’ll get those out of the way first. This movie feels like an eternity and a half. It’s a little complicated, uncomfortable, and sometimes the humor doesn’t quite land. Miles Teller is playing the perfect role of annoying option guy and it’s really hard to tell if it’s acting or not. There always needs to be that more annoying guy, but at points it was a little frustrating to sit through his screen time. So those things made it hard to fully buy in when I felt the choice was so easy from the jump.
Now, there are a lot of positives here so lets get into those. Eternity is so creative! I couldn’t believe something like this hadn’t been put to screen before. Even though I wish the worlds would have been explored a touch more, it was exciting getting to see the behind the scenes of this eternal after life. It asks so many questions. How do you compete with a memory? Who is the best for you? Is it okay to be selfish without regrets? These things have been asked countless times in romcoms, but not in a setting like this.
Now I will say, this movie isn’t the most romantic (probably because I didn’t love either of the male leads), but it has its moments. Elizabeth Olsen in the middle of it all really helps propel the romance forward. Her attendance here is the dreamy glue that holds everything together and she is just so lovely as always. I wish we got more of her and less of the overly comedic and sitcomy style comedy from the rest of the cast. If you didn’t know, this is so much more a comedy than anything else. At times the dark comedy really works, especially since this is technically a dark time in everyone’s life.
It was cathartic, relieving sweet moments of these character’s lives. I’m sure some people will bawl their eyes out at times here, but for me I couldn’t bury myself in some of these characters or the overall comedy. I will say the colors are the most pleasing thing to the eyes here, well, if you don’t count Olsen. Eternity proves that comedy and romance can be both enough and not enough.
I forgot to mention Callum Turner, he’s there too. Hot and there.
3.3/5

